Koi and Goldfish

We currently have fish for sale! And we need help giving them good homes. While we have fish in stock, all fish are BUY 1 Get 1 FREE!

COVID-19 Fish Shopping Guidelines

During the pandemic, we have changed our fish shopping guidelines just a little in order to keep our staff and our customers safe. Watch the brief video below for details or see our posted sign at our shop.

Sizes and Pricing


You'll find a mix of goldfish sold at Cool Ponds -- sarassa, comet (usually orange but can also be brown like the one pictured), and shubunkin (the multi-colored fish pictured).

Goldfish live an average of 6- 8 years and can grow to a maximum of around 10". 

4-5" Mixed Goldfish - 

$7.99 each OR 3 for $20

10-12" Mixed Goldfish - $20.99 each 

The fish we have available now are the LAST we will have for 2020! Don't wait too long to shop. Our next shipment will be for sale April 2021.

Since we keep our fish in outdoor tanks, it is impossible for us to sell koi and goldfish in the late fall and winter months. We look forward to having our usual selection available for you at the end of April 2021!

Domestic Koi

Koi sold at Cool Ponds come in a wide range of colors, including white, yellow, and blue.

Koi are smarter than goldfish, and so are easier to train to eat from your hands. They also have a much longer life expectancy and can grow as long as 36"!

You can purchase a wide range of colors of koi from Cool Ponds. We sort koi in two color grades: Decorative and Select. Select koi have better colors -- bright whites, yellows, and blues, e.g. 


4-6" Standard Fin Koi - $20.99 

4-6" Butterfly Fin Koi - $26.99 


4-6" Standard Fin Koi - $32.99

4-6" Butterfly Fin Koi - $42.99 

Out of Stock Until April 2021:

8" Standard Koi -- $71.99 

8" Butterfly Koi -- $92.99

pond fish indianapolis

What to expect when buying fish.

At Cool Ponds, we sell fish exclusively from outdoor tanks (pictured) during the spring and summer months. We receive new shipments of fish every 1 - 2 weeks.

You won't be getting a "grab bag" assortment. When you pick out the fish you want, that's the one we net up for you!

Your new fish will be bagged in a plastic bag for the transport home, but please do not plan on traveling for more than 45 minutes. Battery-powered aerators can be purchased separately for travel times from 45 min to 90 min.

Cool Ponds Is Here For You


Helpful Links

You deserve your own piece of paradise. We are honored to serve thousands of people just like you across Indiana in building and maintaining beautiful water features. 

More About Our History >

Cool Ponds  |  901 E Hanna Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227  |  Map  |  Tel: 317-786-3670  |  Email: info@coolponds.net

Open Tues - Fri 10am - 5pm, Sat 10am - 3pm; Sun - Mon Closed 

  • Cool Ponds Facebook
  • Cool Ponds Vimeo
  • cool Ponds Blog
  • cool ponds pinterest
  • Cool Ponds of Indy Instagram